In this video, the creator gives credit for each of the song titles and tells where each song comes from (as in which movie they're from). However, there's no credit given to the singers, songwriters, movie producers, or anyone else who took part in making that clip that she has just used. It's assumed she is showing all Disney films because of the title of her video (Top 10 Favorite Disney Songs), but after that, there's no more credit given. Shouldn't there be more somewhere? Shouldn't there be someone else who receives some benefit from this? She really is only using the video to entertain other people, and I don't see much educational value in it as it stands now. Therefore, it's breaking copyright laws for not giving credit and for posting this footage online in a non-educational or benefitting societal way. But who knows, maybe she did actually pay someone?
I love this student group's video for The Giver, and I thought it was a fabulous representation of something I could actually use in my classroom--I might have my students do this same kind of project, actually. I really liked the original photography and cinematography the group used, but I noticed one major problem. They had a song playing in the background (from Coldplay, I think) that they never cited. Probably that should have been mentioned somewhere in their video, just giving a little bit of credit. It fit really well with the video, but when they don't give credit, it breaks copyright laws.
Awesome!
ReplyDeleteGreat commentary! Just so you know, I think we should be considered about citing sources and being careful, but it doesn't need to get too onerous. For example, in your video of the 10 Disney Songs, they're probably fine because they didn't use the whole song (so nobody will steal it because it's not worth stealing!), and they did cite the song and which movie it's from. People now know where to go to learn about the songwriters and all that.
ReplyDeleteGood job!